![]() |
First Handgun - advice sought
I've been lurking here for a while reading as much as I can on the bullion side, but I've just found my way down to this forum and I thought that I would make my 1st post here.
I am juggling a few things around in my life and trying to get my family more prepared for a SHTF scenario. I'm looking for my 1st handgun. I am not new to firearms. I own several shotguns that I use for various forms of bird hunting. I just sold one of the shotguns and I am looking to get a handgun. I have some parameters and thoughts that I am mulling over and I was hoping for some additional input and suggestions. Must Haves: The gun absolutely has to have a "traditional" lever switch or push button type safety. I have 2 kids at home and safety is a primary concern. I do not want the gun to be able to be fired by pulling the trigger alone. This rules out the Glock and other comparable models with the trigger type safetys. This is also a requirement of SWMBO who took much coercing to get to this point so no exceptions here. Use: I want to use the gun for personal protection/household defense, but it needs to be able to be carried without being too bulky should the need arise. I don't anticipate being in a firefight, but if one breaks out I plan on getting the hell out of there ASAP. Capability to stop someone would be good, but also to buy some cover/time. Calibre: I want something in a common calibre so that ammo will be readily available. I was thinking 9mm or .357 would give me the flexibility to shoot .38 as well. Inexpensive ammo is also good. A .45 is probably more than I need and .22 isn't enough. Other: It needs to be affordable. I am looking at $400 +/- budget and I am not opposed to buying used. It needs to be reliable. I don't want to pull the trigger and wonder whether or not it will jam or misfire. Ability to shoot reloads and/or lead bullets reliably would be nice in case of ammo shortage in SHTF scenario. (It is my understanding that some of the newer semi auto barrels don't like lead?) At this point I was thinking that some sort of .357 revolver would meet my criteria. Also looked at the Ruger P95 as an option as it seems to fit most of my needs. I haven't seen or handled anything in person yet which I plan on doing before making any decisions, but I would like to narrow down to a few options before I go to the candy store. Any other suggestions would be appreciated. |
Re: First Handgun - advice sought
|
Re: First Handgun - advice sought
Glock 19.
. |
Re: First Handgun - advice sought
Quote:
Given your requirements, especially for a traditional safety, here she is! (excellent choice - and my personal choice for primary sidearm) |
Re: First Handgun - advice sought
Quote:
Die Glock "safe aktion" ist nicht gut! |
Re: First Handgun - advice sought
I wouldn't own a handgun with a safety, unless it was a target pistol. Defense handguns should go bang when you squeeze the trigger.
So get a safe and change your criteria. Train your kids. "FIRST" Handgun implies there will be a second or more. Get a big safe. The best first gun is a revolver. |
Re: First Handgun - advice sought
1 Attachment(s)
Welcome to GIM. As some GIMer wrote, "I came to GIM for the PMs but I stay for the crazy." Welcome to the asylum.
I too am a bit of gun noob. I grew up with them and shot them, but took a 25 year hiatus. For me, I ended up purchasing Springfield's XD in the 40 S&W. Guaranteed to go bang every time. It was put through a 20,000 (Yes twenty thousand) round torture test. http://springfield-armory.primediaou.../SPstory11.php The gun is 100% reliable. The kicker for me was the safety mechanisms built in. There is NO "catch" safety that you want, but for me the XD's safeties are better. First there is a trigger safety like the Glock but secondly, there is a grip safety. It is impossible for a small hand to properly grip the gun and fire it. With a "catch" safety a small hand could still switch the gun to "hot" and pull the trigger. My little girl could NOT shoot the XD if she wanted to. For me, hands down it was the XD. I will say, I did do a lot of research and went to the gun shops, asked lots of questions and held lots of guns. If the gun does not fit well in your hand, forget about buying it, no matter how much of a recommendation it has. If you decide on the XD, avoid the XDM. Only because of price. XDM is significantly more expensive. Ofcourse, you can hold more rounds in the mag (I think 15 for the XDM versus 12 for the XD and there are changeable backstraps for the grip. Oh, and since you started this thread, you are obligated to tell us what you purchased and if you have a pic or two, that would be great. We love gun porn!!! :applause_:applause_:applause_ The Great Ag |
Re: First Handgun - advice sought
Hoarder - I completely see your point, but I've got to keep the domestic peace and I've got to start somewhere. I grew up in a house with guns and was taught safety at an early age.
The Great Ag - I like the XD, but it is probably going to be a little beyond what I am looking to spend initially. |
Re: First Handgun - advice sought
Quote:
Not sure what prices are today. I bought my gun very early this year. The Great Ag |
Re: First Handgun - advice sought
As soon as I can free up some FRNs the SR9 is going to be mine! $379.95 Delivered
|
Re: First Handgun - advice sought
sig 226..............
|
Re: First Handgun - advice sought
So far, great suggestions. I would recommend finding a range that allows you to rent handguns, and try a few different models, calibers, etc. before deciding.
I did that and settled on an XD40, which I found for under 500FRN. My wife prefers 9mm, and she found a nice Smith 3913, used for under 400. Best of luck in your search. |
Re: First Handgun - advice sought
One benefit to a magazine-fed pistol, shotgun, or rifle is that the loaded magazine can be secured separately from the weapon and yet still be inserted and the weapon quickly deployed in an emergency.
With a revolver, keep ammo in speed-loaders in a separate location. Police trade-in Glocks in 9mm or 40SW retail around $300...They have been inspected throughly, refurbished if necessary, and are in very good to excellent shape with many years of service life left. |
Re: First Handgun - advice sought
I had very good results with my Taurus MilPro PT111. The newest ones (3rd generation)work very well and it has the traditional safety. I am like you. I had to buy the first gun with a traditional safety. The other I considered was a stoeger cougar. Both are lower priced than the glocks/xds. My next gun I am looking to get a Glock or XD
|
Re: First Handgun - advice sought
This is also a requirement of SWMBO who took much coercing to get to this point so no exceptions here.
??????????? T |
Re: First Handgun - advice sought
Quote:
|
Re: First Handgun - advice sought
Quote:
|
Re: First Handgun - advice sought
Thanks cuz I thought it meant:
Socialist Wizard, Master Barack Obama:36_1_32v: |
Re: First Handgun - advice sought
Branshew,
You mention .357 which is a great caliber. A used Smith & Wesson or Ruger chambered for .357 would be a good 1st handgun. Simple design, ease of use, etc. The trigger lock or one of the the pistol safes that are available as a safety option would allow you to keep the gun loaded but inaccessible to small curious hands. Or the revolver kept empty with speedloaders in a separate location possibly. Example of the pistol safe: http://www.safetysafeguards.com/site...uct/GV1000CSTD Kids are inquisitive and will explore if given the chance, (I did). Gun safety/education along with trips to the range for trigger time will be the best guard against an accident. Might want to think about picking up a .22 revolver as well for cheap practice, plus it would be something to use when you familarize the kids with shooting. I've never been around a child that didn't take to shooting like a duck to water once they were given the chance. Reactive targets are the best ones to use when they are starting out. By making the choice to keep guns in the house you have also chosen to raise the children in a pro second amendment atmosphere. Good on your for that choice! My parents did the same thing and I am damn glad they did. Failing to educate them about the shooting sports so they learn first hand that guns are NOT bad will send mixed signals and have them only exposed to the other side of the argument that is in their face daily via tv and school. Sorry for the rant. Back on topic, I vote revolver for the first handgun. Happy New Year. |
Re: First Handgun - advice sought
Quote:
With the .357 I could shoot less expensive .38 for practice and put the real loads in for defense. Having a flexibility of ammo would be good in a SHTF scenario and a revolver should be able to handle reloads and lead better than most semi-autos. I just missed out on a S&W 66-1 that a local guy had for sale at $275. We've got a show coming up this weekend so I'll probably stop in to see what is available. |
Re: First Handgun - advice sought
The Smith 66 is a great choice along with the 65 if you are a fan of fixed rather than adjustable sights. Ruger made a model for years call the Security Six that is a good option as well. Being able to shoot both 38 & 357 is a big benefit. Check out those trigger locks too. You could keep the key on your keyring and the gun cannot be used with the lock in place. If you are a reloader, you would really be able to cut the cost of practice ammo.
Good luck at the show! |
Re: First Handgun - advice sought
Quote:
http://www.summitgunbroker.com/Glock_22.html Having said that, if you JUST GOTTA HAVE a safety switch, here's a used Sig 229 in .40 S&W w/nite sites and two 12 round mags. $499 Please note that this feature (in the Sig) adds over $170 (vs the Glock) AND well over your $400 limit and this is for USED. http://www.summitgunbroker.com/used_229.html With EITHER of these firearms, you can drop in a .357 sig barrel and you have a two caliber handgun. WITH THE GLOCK 22, you can swap in a 9mm barrel and 9mm mags and you have a three caliber platform. Here's a Sig 226 CPO (Certified Pre-Owned - the RED label around the firearm) in .40 S&W for $545. I do NOT believe that Sig currently makes any swap in barrels for the 226 (I could be wrong). Though other barrel manufacturers might. http://www.summitgunbroker.com/_P226_CPO.html Revolvers? .38/.357 is NOT a bad choice. We own a 6" Dan Wesson, a couple of Taurus 6 shot 4", a couple of Rossi 6 shot 2" barrel and a Rossi Lever Action rifle (this last addition is for my wife and goes well with HER 4" Taurus pistols - she's a better shot that I am). Though most ANY manufacturer's revolvers will do. Rossi 4" pistol 6 shot http://www.rossiusa.com/product-deta...eadcrumbseries= Rossi 2" pistol 6 shot http://www.rossiusa.com/product-deta...eadcrumbseries= Lever Action 12 shot (in the 20" or 24" barrel) http://www.rossiusa.com/product-list.cfm?category=8 I concur that if you purchase a revolver, get a handfull of speed loaders for it. They should cost between $10 and $20 each (cheaper if you can find them used). We use both semi-auto and revolver. Nothing wrong with either or both. Though even used you will be hard pressed to find a used semi-auto for under $400 (though that Glock 22 for $330 IS a steal). You should be able to find a good used .357 for $400 or less. The Rossi 2" was purchased new for around $225 (several years ago) and the Taurus 4" was about $350 (more than ten years ago). The Rossi M92 Lever Action rifle in 16" barrel trapper size we just picked up new for $400. I had a pair of sling swivels added by my gunsmithing buddy, as I use him for all my paperwork transfers. Hope that helps. OH, and about Glock. Just in case you AIN'T seen this link... http://www.theprepared.com/index.php...iew&id=90&Item He added in some info about an H&K (which I actually like) since the last time I read this and the compact USP did NOT do well. AT ALL. The GLOCK is the AK of handguns. |
Re: First Handgun - advice sought
Quote:
|
Re: First Handgun - advice sought
Quote:
The OP said he was experienced with gun but then he only mentioned rifles and shotguns. He didn't give us any idea of his actual hands-on handgun experience. I never recommend an auto for somebody who hasn't already got substantial handgun usage under their belt. I can live with something like a Ruger MKII .22 LR for a newbie range gun since I know they are only going to be loading and unloading at the range and they aren't going to try to carry it. Everybody else, a revolver is really a better (and safer) way to start. A revolver doesn't need a safety because of the double action trigger. (Let's just ignore the whole SA style of revolver for now. Keep things simple!) If you can train yourself and your family to never cock the hammer, you've got a perfectly safe gun without a safety. Every police department in the US used DA revolvers for decades and lack of a safety was never an issue. That long heavy trigger pull isn't going to happen by mistake. Far, far easier for a child to click off a safety on an auto than to pull your typical DA trigger. My number one reason for recommending revolvers is the whole loading/unloading drill. A newbie who is going to be loading and unloading your typical auto gives me the willies. Some autos have to be taken off safety just to withdraw the slide. The force required to work the slide can be more than some untrained women can handle. And newbies get confused by the whole "loaded magazine withdrawn but still a round in the chamber" routine. (The TV and movie producers can't figure it out either!) With a revolver, you open the cylinder and there are all the chambers right in front of you. Easy to see whether there are rounds inserted or not. You can safely open and close that cylinder a thousand times and you never have to worry about accidentally touching the trigger. I have a family rule that we don't load or unload guns in the house. Take it out to the porch. The only exception is DA revolvers. You are right that medium frame .38/.357 revolvers are very flexible. That's where I started on my 21st birthday back in 1982. Ruger Security Six. Box of .38 wadcutters and another box of 125 grain JHP's. I quickly realized I needed to start reloading so those were the only two boxes of factory ammo I ever bought for that gun. I would look on gunbroker for some type of used revolver of the "police duty type." A S&W Model 19 or 66 would be ideal. Probably a four inch barrel. The newer L frames would be fine (581/586/681/686) although they are larger and heavier. I love the old N frames like the Model 28 but they are large enough that you won't be carrying them. If I was actually going to carry a duty size .357 as a CCW gun, I think I would look for a S&W M13 or M65. Certainly nothing wrong with a Ruger Speed Six in that role either. I used to carry a S&W M640 but that's a Centennial style snub and I don't think it would be an ideal first handgun by any means. Start out middle size and then go from there. Gregg |
Re: First Handgun - advice sought
Quote:
|
Re: First Handgun - advice sought
It has been mentioned a few times in this thread and I concure, a revolver is your best option at this stage in your firearms life. .357mag/.38 spec is an excellent choice IMO.
|
Re: First Handgun - advice sought
My wife is small and could not handle the slide on my Ruger 345. I bought her a Taurus 38 special aluminum frame snub nose. She is happy with it. It is +P rated, I won't give her the +P loads until she carries it. Practice with 38 special loads. Sent her to a range and paid for training (do not recommend spousal training to save marriage). Also got her a concealed carry permit.
|
Re: First Handgun - advice sought
Quote:
|
Re: First Handgun - advice sought
Quote:
You guys aren't making this any easier for me. |
Re: First Handgun - advice sought
We've hashed this out a few times, but imo, with the rise of multiple perp home invasions...you'd better have 2 revolvers handy.
The SR9 is slim and easy to tuck in for carry and it also has a capacity of 17+1. |
| All times are GMT -4. The time now is 10:38 AM. |
Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.4
Copyright ©2000 - 2010, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
Copyright = None use it and Link to GIM